Where the Sound Meets the Soil: The Magic of Baiting Hollow

Imagine a place where the salt air of the Long Island Sound drifts over rows of ripening grapevines and century-old farm stands. This is Baiting Hollow, a hamlet that serves as the literal and metaphorical gateway to New York’s famed North Fork. At the heart of this pastoral landscape lies 125 Northgate Circle, a property that captures the essence of modern Long Island living while remaining deeply rooted in the region’s rich agricultural heritage.

The home, a meticulously maintained 1997 Colonial, is currently listed for $789,000. It sits on a nearly half-acre lot that acts as a bridge between the suburban comfort of the late 20th century and the wild, natural beauty of the Sound. Here, the hustle of the city feels like a distant memory, replaced by the rhythm of the seasons and the quiet hum of a community that values its space and its history.

The Architectural Narrative: A Modern Homestead

The layout of 125 Northgate Circle is a masterclass in functional elegance. Spanning 1,995 square feet, the home operates like a well-oiled machine, where the kitchen acts as the conductor of the household’s daily orchestra. The sun-drenched foyer welcomes visitors with an open and airy feel, leading seamlessly into a spacious eat-in kitchen that flows directly into the living and dining areas.

Space to Grow

The second level is a sanctuary for the modern family, featuring an expansive primary suite with vaulted ceilings and a walk-in closet that rivals the size of a small New York City apartment. With three additional bedrooms, the home offers a versatility that is increasingly rare at this price point. The unfinished basement provides a blank canvas—a ‘versatile theater of possibilities’—ready to be transformed into a home gym, a private office, or a high-end media room.

Recent upgrades ensure peace of mind for the next owner: the roof is only seven years young, and the heating system was replaced just four years ago. This isn’t just a house; it’s a fortified investment in lifestyle. [Explore more Baiting Hollow homes]

A Walk Through History: From Horse Trails to Vineyards

The name ‘Baiting Hollow’ itself is a nod to a bygone era. In the 18th century, the area featured a prominent pond where travelers along the 1702 cart path (now Sound Avenue) would ‘bait’—or feed and water—their horses. This was the ‘Great Woods’ of Long Island, a rugged terrain that once saw action during the War of 1812. In 1814, local militia famously repelled British forces attempting to seize wood-carrying vessels at nearby landings.

Today, that same spirit of preservation is alive. The Baiting Hollow Congregational Church, founded in 1791, still stands as the ‘Church on the Hill,’ a sentinel overlooking the growth of the North Fork’s wine industry. Living at 125 Northgate Circle means living within a living museum, where every farm stand and historic marker tells a story of American resilience.

The Financials: A Pulse on the 11933 Market

The real estate market in zip code 11933 is currently experiencing a renaissance. According to recent data from Zillow and Realtor.com, home values in the area have appreciated by approximately 4.3% over the past year, with a median list price hovering around $616,500. However, homes like 125 Northgate Circle, which offer proximity to the Sound and turnkey conditions, frequently command a premium.

“Baiting Hollow is the rare market where you can still find value compared to the astronomical prices of the Hamptons, while enjoying a superior connection to nature and viticulture.” — Elite Real Estate Analysis 2026.

With annual taxes of approximately $11,309 and a nominal HOA fee of $750 that grants access to private community circles and beach entries, the financial profile of this property is highly competitive for the region. It is a ‘buy-and-hold’ goldmine in an area where land is finite and demand is infinite.

Lifestyle & Amenities: The North Fork Experience

Life in Baiting Hollow is defined by its proximity to the water and the vine. Residents are just minutes from the Baiting Hollow Farm Vineyard and the Riverhead Ciderhouse, which host community events ranging from the North Fork Foodie Tour to live music weekends. For the outdoor enthusiast, Wildwood State Park offers miles of hiking trails and some of the most dramatic bluffs on the East Coast.

• Education: Zoned for the Riley Avenue School, which boasts high ratings for its community-focused learning environment.
• Safety: Baiting Hollow maintains an A+ safety rating, with crime rates significantly lower than the national average (AreaVibes 2025).
• Recreation: Proximity to the Baiting Hollow Club, a world-class golf course designed by Robert Trent Jones.

The Verdict

125 Northgate Circle is more than a four-bedroom Colonial; it is a ticket to a lifestyle that many dream of but few attain. It offers the rare combination of 18th-century charm and 21st-century convenience. Whether you are sipping local Chardonnay on your private deck or exploring the historic horse trails of the Great Woods, this home provides a serene backdrop for a life well-lived. In the competitive landscape of Long Island real estate, this property stands out as a lighthouse of value and character. [View more North Fork listings]

Related Videos

• 
  ▶ Baiting Hollow, NY Neighborhood Tour
  

Property Details

• Acreage:0.49 Acres
• HOA Fees:$750 per year
• ✓ Located in the ‘Gateway to the North Fork’ near Baiting Hollow Farm Vineyard.
• ✓ Property features a 7-year-young roof and a 4-year-young burner.
• ✓ Includes membership potential for Baiting Hollow Estates with private Sound beach access.
• ✓ Zoned for the highly-regarded Riley Avenue Elementary School (Riverhead School District).
• ✓ Equipped with a 4-zone underground sprinkler system and a private backyard oasis.

Interested?

Contact me to see the property.