Massapequa doesn’t make a lot of noise. It doesn’t need to. Tucked along the South Shore of Nassau County, it has been quietly doing what Long Island suburbs do best — good schools, tree-lined blocks, the kind of neighborhood where people plant roots and stay. That steadiness shows up in the market too: homes here don’t sit long, and when a well-maintained split-level hits at $779,000 in the Plainedge School District, it moves. This one already has.
49 Amherst Drive is pending, which tells you something on its own. In a market where buyers are selective and financing is still navigating elevated rates — we covered exactly what that means for Long Island right now in The Impact of Interest Rates on Long Island Buyers Right Now — a home going under contract quickly is a statement. Good bones, honest pricing, and the right school district will always find their buyer.
The Property: What You’re Looking At
Built in 1953 and listed via EXIT Realty Premier, 49 Amherst Drive is a single-family split-level with 1,499 square feet of living space on a 0.16-acre lot. Four bedrooms. One and a half baths. A two-plus car driveway. The kind of layout that works — not because it’s spectacular on paper, but because it flows.
The main level opens into a bright living room, dining room, and kitchen, arranged for easy daily movement and comfortable entertaining. Upstairs, two generously sized bedrooms share a full bath, and the primary suite occupies its own level with a private bath — a detail that matters more than people sometimes realize until they’ve lived in a house without one.
The fourth bedroom is the standout. At 19 feet by 14 feet, it sits on the upper level and functions as something different for every buyer who sees it: a true primary suite alternative, a home office large enough to mean it, a guest wing, a creative space. It includes a large closet and access to attic storage, which adds practical square footage that doesn’t show up in the official count but absolutely shows up in daily life.
The Plainedge Advantage
Plainedge Union Free School District is the quiet credential that drives Massapequa pricing on this side of town. Consistently rated among Nassau County’s stronger districts, Plainedge draws buyers who have done the research and arrived at the same conclusion: the school boundaries matter, and being inside them matters more than a few thousand dollars of asking price.
The district serves students from kindergarten through twelfth grade, with Plainedge High School recognized for strong academics and a solid college placement record. For families putting down roots with children in the picture, it’s one of the first filters applied to any search in this zip code — and 49 Amherst Drive clears it cleanly.
South Shore Massapequa: The Neighborhood Context
Massapequa sits between Seaford to the west and Amityville to the east, with the Southern State Parkway running through the middle and the waterways of the South Shore just minutes south. It’s commuter-practical — the LIRR’s Babylon Branch puts Penn Station roughly an hour away — and it retains the kind of neighborhood character that makes people stop renting and start buying.
The Massapequa Preserve, a 432-acre green space that connects Bethpage State Park to the north and Jones Beach to the south along bike trails and walking paths, gives this part of Nassau County something most suburbs can’t offer: real open land, right in the middle of everything. Local parks, golf courses, and the waterfront add to a lifestyle profile that tends to surprise buyers who haven’t spent time on the South Shore.
For those still building their picture of what Long Island offers across its full range of communities, Long Island vs. Westchester: Where Should You Plant Roots? walks through some of those broader comparisons, and Best Commuter Towns on Long Island for NYC Professionals covers the commute math that matters for buyers splitting time between the Island and the city.
Reading the Pending Status
A listing going pending quickly doesn’t just mean one buyer moved fast. It means the pricing was right, the home showed well, and demand in this pocket of Nassau County is active. The Long Island Real Estate Market Update: Q1 2026 documented the broader trend: well-priced, well-maintained homes in strong school districts continue to attract competitive interest even as buyers work within tighter financing conditions.
That dynamic is worth understanding even for buyers who weren’t interested in this specific property. The inventory reality on Long Island — particularly in Nassau County, in established districts, at the $700K–$900K range — means that when something like 49 Amherst Drive comes available, the window is short. Buyers who are pre-approved and clear on their priorities move. Those who are still deciding tend to miss it.
If you’re building your search strategy and want guidance on what’s available across Long Island right now, Paola “Pawli” Meyer, Associate Broker at Maison Pawli Realty, works with buyers and sellers across Nassau and Suffolk County and can put context around what listings like this one signal about where the market is heading.
The Specs at a Glance
Address: 49 Amherst Drive, Massapequa, NY 11758
MLS #: 953174
Listed by: EXIT Realty Premier
Status: Pending
Price: $779,000
Style: Split-Level
Year Built: 1953
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 1 full, 1 half
Square Footage: 1,499 sq ft
Lot Size: 0.16 acres
School District: Plainedge Union Free School District
Driveway: Two-plus car
You Might Also Like
- Long Island Real Estate Market Update: Q1 2026
- The Impact of Interest Rates on Long Island Buyers Right Now
- First-Time Homebuyer’s Roadmap for Long Island in 2026
