The Hamburger Deluxe at The Heritage Diner in Mount Sinai is served on a toasted seeded bun, with potatoes, onion rings, lettuce, tomato, coleslaw and pickles, according to its Cash App listing, for $14.75.
What “deluxe” adds
The burger arrives as a full plate. Lettuce and tomato go on the sandwich, and the sides carry the rest: potatoes, a stack of onion rings, a cup of coleslaw and a pickle. The seeded bun is toasted, a small step that keeps the bottom half intact against the juices.
It is the shape of the American diner burger plate, and the plate has a contested family tree.

The Library of Congress claim
The best-documented origin story points to Connecticut. A Scripps News report says the Library of Congress credits Louis’ Lunch in New Haven with creating the country’s first hamburger in 1900. Connecticut History says Representative Rosa DeLauro pushed for official recognition of Louis Lassen as the creator of the hamburger, and that the Library of Congress recorded the claim.
Louis’ Lunch still serves burgers on toast, not buns. George Motz, author of Hamburger America, disputes the origin story but, as Fox News reported, remains a fan of the place and says Lassen at the least helped popularize the hamburger.
The other claimants
Others say they were first. According to Connecticut History, challenges have come from Hamburg, New York, and Seymour, Wisconsin, though both rely on oral history instead of documents. Texas has its own candidate. A Tasting Table overview of the debate says even the Library of Congress recognition has not stopped the argument, and a Wikipedia history of the hamburger in the United States attributes the invention to Fletcher Davis of Athens, Texas, citing the historian Frank X. Tolbert.
No single account settles it, which is part of why the burger belongs to everyone.

From Hamburg to the lunch counter
The name points to Germany. Scripps notes that most accounts credit German-speaking immigrants who brought a dish called the Hamburg steak to the United States in the mid-1800s. Putting the ground patty between bread, whoever first did it, was the American step: it made the meal portable.

Ordering the Hamburger Deluxe
The direct item link is cash.app/$heritagedinerli/item/CALI_CAESGEhWT0dVVlY1QUFXUFJQTTVEWTJEUFZFUBgB. Every burger and sandwich on the menu is listed on the Heritage Diner menu page. The diner is at 275 Route 25A, Mount Sinai, NY, and since items and prices change, (631) 642-3700 confirms what is current.
Sources
- Scripps News: The American Hamburger Was Born In New Haven, Conn.
- Connecticut History: Louis’ Lunch and the Birth of the Hamburger
- Fox News: Louis Lassen and the American hamburger
- Tasting Table: The Birthplace Of The Hamburger Is A Heated Debate
- Wikipedia: History of the hamburger in the United States (cited for the Texas claim only)
- Heritage Diner on Cash App: Hamburger Deluxe
You might also like
The images in this post, including the featured photo from the diner’s Cash App listing, are AI-generated reference images and may vary slightly from the dish as served. Real food photos are on the Heritage Diner Facebook page.


Leave a Reply