The syrup-and-nut pie on the Thanksgiving table is younger than its reputation, and the corporate origin story attached to it does not survive the cookbooks.
Pecan pie as it is baked now, with a filling of syrup, eggs, sugar and butter poured over pecans, is a twentieth-century dish. Rebecca Sharpless, author of the book Grain and Fire, said so in a 2022 post for the UNC Press blog, and added that any recipe sold as “Old South Pecan Pie” is bogus.
The label story
The version most Americans know ties the pie to Karo corn syrup. Sharpless writes that Karo itself dates to 1902, and that the company’s website carried a line crediting the pie’s invention to the wife of a Karo employee, likely in Chicago. Her own book repeated that line. In the UNC Press post she calls it “dead wrong,” and says she took the corporate account at face value without checking it. The Nibble, a food-history blog, reports a slightly different version of the same company line: that the recipe came from the wife of a senior sales executive in the 1930s.

Her corrected account starts with paper. The earliest Karo-based pecan pie she found is in a 1925 Sunday school cookbook from First Baptist Church of Dallas, credited to Mrs. H. W. Woodruff and calling for dark Karo. She found no earlier recipe that used the syrup. The pie and the product were linked early, and the link stuck.
Dark Karo, the type named in that 1925 recipe, is still sold. Karo Dark Corn Syrup with Refined Molasses, 16 fl oz is the bottle in question. See it on Amazon (affiliate link)
Other sources date the label recipe later. Tasting History says Karo printed a pecan pie recipe on its corn syrup labels in the 1930s and credits that with boosting the pie’s popularity. The Nibble publishes a recipe from Mrs. Frank Herring, printed in the Sallisaw, Oklahoma, Democrat American on February 19, 1931, as one of the earliest to swap Karo in for sorghum or molasses; it also calls for corn meal. The 1925 Dallas recipe predates it, and Sharpless’s Memphis and Mississippi bakery ads from 1929 predate it too.
A 1914 recipe with no syrup at all
The recipe in the video above is older than any Karo version Sharpless found. Tasting History’s page gives its source as the “Tried Recipes” column of the Christian Science Monitor on March 24, 1914, titled “Texas Pecan Pie.” The original takes one cup of sweet milk, one cup of sugar, three well-beaten eggs, a tablespoon of flour and half a cup of finely chopped pecans, cooked together, poured into a rich crust and baked. Egg whites beaten with two tablespoons of sugar go on top as a meringue, browned lightly in the oven.

That is a custard. Sweetened with plain sugar and set by eggs and flour, it comes out smooth rather than gelatinous, and the page’s author says this pre-corn-syrup style has more pecan flavor and is less sweet than modern versions.
Max Miller’s adaptation on the same page uses brown sugar, whole milk, a pinch of salt and pecan halves on top. It blind-bakes the crust, cooks the filling gently on the stove so the eggs do not scramble, bakes at 350°F until the center has a slight wobble, and bakes the meringue for about 12 minutes. The page says the earliest mention of pecan pie its author found dates to 1886.
Pies before the syrup
Pecan pies existed before Karo, and they were a different dish. Sharpless found that pre-1900 pecan pies were cream pies with nuts, and that the type persisted into the 1930s. A 1922 Texas recipe from Myrtle Mainer Neff is one example. In the late 1920s the San Saba Pecan Company in San Saba, Texas, promoted “Mrs. Bell’s famous pecan pie,” which was also cream-based.

Two older recipes came close without matching. She looked at an 1879 molasses pie recipe from a “Mrs. Dr. J.,” likely of Virginia, and an 1905 English treacle tart recipe by Mrs. A. S. Peel. Neither matched the modern pie, which she abbreviates as PPAWKI, for the modern pecan pie.
The earliest-recipe date moves with the source. Wikipedia’s summary of the dish, used here as a pointer rather than a primary source, says attempts to trace the pie have found no recipe earlier than a pecan custard pie published in Harper’s Bazaar in 1886, and that pre-corn-syrup versions used darker sugar syrup or molasses. A Tasting Table summary of an Eater history, by contrast, says the dessert was originally a Texas invention found in cookbooks as early as 1898.
Bakery cases, 1929 to 1932
By the end of the 1920s the pie was a retail item. Sharpless found a 1929 Memphis ad for Vieh Bakeries selling “Vieh’s Karo Pecan Pie” for thirty-three cents, and a Karo pecan pie from Delta Baking Company in Clarksville, Mississippi, at forty cents. In 1930, Big Chain’s Balcony Cafeteria in Shreveport sold a Karo pecan pie for ten cents a slice. A 1932 recipe titled “Pecan Pie (New Orleans)” in Sheila Hibben’s The National Cookbook uses Karo, brown sugar and a single crust.
Slidell, Louisiana, 1900
The recipe that comes nearest the modern pie without Karo sits in A Book of Famous Old New Orleans Recipes, which Sharpless dates to 1900. Its pecan pie, on page 47, uses “Louisiana syrup,” meaning cane syrup rather than corn syrup. The book’s editor says Slidell appears to be the pie’s original home. Sharpless could find little more on the Slidell pie, and the claim rests on that single printed source.
Where the evidence stops
Four claims sit side by side in the record. The Karo company’s account, an employee’s or executive’s wife, is disputed by the historian who once repeated it. The Texas cream-pie tradition is documented but is a different filling. The 1914 Christian Science Monitor recipe is a syrup-free custard that already carried the name “Texas Pecan Pie.” The Slidell recipe is closest in construction and is a single page in a single book.
What the paper does support is narrower: Karo helped spread the modern pie, and at least one version existed with cane syrup instead. Home cooks had been baking pecan pies in several forms for years before the bottle’s label gave one of them a standard shape.
More Thanksgiving-week reading from the diner: the hot turkey sandwich, pumpkin pie without cracks, and the flaky all-butter crust.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. A commission may be earned if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Rebecca Sharpless, A Fresh Look at the History of Pecan Pie, UNC Press Blog, Nov. 16, 2022: https://uncpressblog.com/2022/11/16/a-fresh-look-at-the-history-of-pecan-pie/
- Tasting History, Pecan Pie recipe page: https://www.tastinghistory.com/recipes/pecanpie
- The Nibble, Chocolate Pecan Pie Recipe & The History Of Pecans: https://blog.thenibble.com/2017/08/20/recipe-chocolate-pecan-pie/
- Tasting Table, The Historic Connection Between Pecan Pie And Karo Syrup: https://tastingtable.com/841833/the-historic-connection-between-pecan-pie-and-karo-syrup
- Wikipedia, Pecan pie (pointer only): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pecan_pie
- Tasting History with Max Miller, The Best Pecan Pie Recipe is from 1914: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwhN1sOUCnE


Leave a Reply