The Millennium Diner: A Smithtown Staple Since 2000
In the ever-changing landscape of Long Island dining, few things are as comforting as a classic diner. For residents of Smithtown, the Millennium Diner at 156 East Main Street has been that constant beacon of neon light and hot coffee for nearly 25 years.
Whether you are a local looking for the history of your favorite breakfast spot or a visitor passing through on Route 25, here is everything you need to know about this iconic eatery.
Planning a Visit?
- Address: 156 East Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787
- Hours: Open 7 Days a week (Check Google for Holiday hours)
- Phone: (631) 360-2210
Origins & History: A New Diner for a New Era
As the name suggests, the Millennium Diner was born at the turn of the century. Opening its doors in 2000, it was designed to be a modern take on the classic Greek diner experience.
The property itself sits at a critical junction in Smithtown—right near the intersection of Routes 111 and 25 (Main Street). Before the stainless steel structure of the Millennium arrived, this corridor was already a busy commercial hub, but the arrival of the diner cemented it as a “meet-up spot” for locals. Unlike many diners that have changed hands or names repeatedly, the Millennium has remained a family-owned and operated business for over two decades. The owners, the Pavlatos family, have managed to keep the doors open even as other local diners have shuttered due to rising rents and operating costs.
The Menu: “Millennium Munchies” and More
The Millennium Diner is famous for its massive menu. It is the kind of place where you can order Eggs Benedict at 8:00 PM or a burger at 8:00 AM.
Notable Menu Sections:
- Millennium Munchies: This is their signature late-night or appetizer section, featuring everything from mozzarella sticks to loaded potato skins.
- The Omelet King: They are renowned for their omelets. The “Millennium Omelet” is a local legend—packed with broccoli, mushrooms, cheese, and tomatoes. Reviews often mention that the portion size is so large the home fries have to be stacked on top of the omelet just to fit on the plate.
- Greek Specialties: staying true to its roots, the diner offers authentic spinach pie (spanakopita) and souvlaki that rivals dedicated Greek restaurants.
View the Full Menu & Order:
Community & Culture
The Millennium Diner isn’t just about food; it is a political and social hub.
- The “Power Breakfast”: It is a well-known secret that local politicians and Smithtown officials frequently use the Millennium as a meeting ground. If you go on a Tuesday morning, you might just overhear the planning of the next town budget.
- Car Culture: While the diner itself doesn’t host an official car show, it is the unofficial pre-game spot for the Saturday Night Car Shows held nearby at the Stop & Shop parking lot on West Main Street. In the summer, it is common to see classic Mustangs and Corvettes parked in the Millennium lot as drivers fuel up before the show.
Notable Reviews
“Put simply, every town needs a Millennium Diner. The restaurant has all the ingredients of a classic diner… a personal family owned and operated business strategy and a casual atmosphere that doubles as a professional meeting place.” — Patch.com Review