1 Daylilly Court, Middle Island, NY 11953 — A Victorian Colonial With Endless Potential (MLS# 976744)

Listing Link: https://portal.onehome.com/en-US/share/2097424Q77467#

Opportunity is knocking in the Pine Ridge section of The Preserves—and this one is all about potential. Set on a generous .58‑acre corner lot, this 4‑bedroom, 2.5‑bath Victorian Colonial offers space, structure, and the kind of layout today’s buyers are searching for. With a little vision and some thoughtful updates, this 2000‑built home can truly shine.

🏡 Property Overview

  • MLS#: 976744
  • Address: 1 Daylilly Court, Middle Island, NY 11953
  • Price: $669,999
  • Beds/Baths: 4 Bedrooms • 2 Full Baths • 1 Half Bath
  • Square Footage: 2,148 sq ft
  • Lot Size: 0.56–0.58 acres (corner lot)
  • Year Built: 2000
  • School District: Longwood SD

What Makes This Home Stand Out

A True Victorian Colonial Layout

The home features a classic, functional floor plan with an open kitchen/living room, a formal dining area, and cathedral ceilings that bring in natural light. The primary suite includes a private bath, with three additional bedrooms on the second floor—ideal for families or anyone needing extra space.

Room to Grow

A full unfinished basement with 8′ ceilings and an outside entrance offers tremendous potential—home gym, recreation room, storage, or future finished living space.

Outdoor Space That Works for You

The oversized lot provides privacy, play space, and the possibility of adding a pool. The oversized driveway fits 4+ cars, plus a 2‑car garage—a rare convenience.

Modern Essentials Already in Place

  • Natural gas heat
  • Public water
  • Laundry/mud room on the main level
  • Separate water heater

🔧 A Home Ready for Your Personal Touch

This property is perfect for buyers who want to customize a home to their taste. The structure is solid, the layout is desirable, and the neighborhood is established—making this a smart long‑term investment. Some systems (CAC and dishwasher) are noted as as‑is, giving buyers the opportunity to upgrade with their preferred finishes.

📍 Location: Pine Ridge at The Preserves

Middle Island offers a balance of suburban quiet and convenience, with access to parks, preserves, shopping, and major roadways. The Longwood School District is consistently sought after for its programs and community reputation.

🔗 View the Full Listing & Photos

Click below to explore the official OneKey MLS listing, property details, and upcoming open house information:

👉 https://portal.onehome.com/en-US/share/2097424Q77467#

Similar Posts