93 S Main St, Middleville NY — A Rare Victorian Opportunity $44,900

ByStaff

In the heart of Middleville sits a true 19th‑century gem — a Queen Anne–style Victorian with unmistakable curb appeal, original craftsmanship, and nearly 3,000 sq ft of potential. Priced at $44,900, this 1860-built home at 93 S Main St is one of those rare opportunities that almost never appear in the West Canada Valley School District, a district known for strong community roots and consistent demand.

This property is ideal for anyone who loves historic architecture, wants a renovation project with serious upside, or is looking to invest in a village setting with long-term value.

🌳 A Victorian With Character, Charm & Endless Possibilities

Even before stepping inside, the home’s exterior tells a story:

  • Gingerbread trim & decorative shingling
  • Wraparound front porch perfect for summer evenings
  • High-pitched rooflines & classic Queen Anne detailing
  • Large 0.6‑acre lot with room for gardens, patios, or future outdoor living spaces

The curb appeal alone is impressive — especially at this price point.

🏠 Inside the Home: Historic Craftsmanship Meets Wide‑Open Potential

The interior offers 2,863 sq ft of space, high ceilings, and oversized windows that flood the home with natural light. Original details include:

  • Newel posts & stair rails
  • Gorgeous mouldings
  • Hardwood floors
  • Large, sun-filled rooms

The layout is surprisingly functional for a home of this era, including:

  • A first‑floor bedroom or den
  • A massive kitchen footprint
  • Multiple large living spaces

This home needs a full renovation, but the bones are exceptional — and the floor plan is far more flexible than most 1860s homes. The seller even notes a $200k renovation scope, which would still put the total investment far below the value of comparable restored Victorian homes in the region.

💡 Why This Property Is a Standout Opportunity

  • Nearly 3,000 sq ft of living space
  • Strong school district with consistent buyer demand
  • Historic architecture that’s increasingly rare
  • Large village lot
  • Instant equity potential after renovation
  • Priced at just $44,900

For investors, renovators, or anyone dreaming of restoring a Victorian, this is a chance to create something truly special.

🗺️ Location Highlights

Middleville offers a quiet village lifestyle with easy access to:

  • West Canada Valley schools
  • Local shops & services
  • Scenic rural surroundings
  • Nearby Little Falls, Herkimer, and Utica

It’s a peaceful setting with a strong sense of community — ideal for anyone looking to escape the noise without sacrificing convenience.

📝 Listing Attribution

Listing Courtesy of: THE BOUTIQUE REAL ESTATE SHOPPE Listing Agent: Nathaniel Crossett — 315‑717‑4058 MLS#: 11615957 Source: NY State MLS

🔗 View the Full Listing on Zillow

https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/93-S-Main-St-Middleville-NY-13406/215862303_zpid

Similar Posts