Setauket Seafood and Italy’s Village Market — 230 and 232 Main Street, East Setauket, NY 11733
Two counters on East Setauket’s Main Street, a fish market that lasted 42 years and a butcher shop reopened this summer, and the chef who kept both going.
Peter Pan Diner, 999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, NY 11706
The Peter Pan Diner in Bay Shore opened in 1955, has been run by the Lentzeres family since 1959, and reopened in March 2026 after a kitchen fire kept it dark for about twenty months.
Stranger Things Diner NYC: What We Know So Far
Netflix’s Stranger Things: The Diner is headed to Manhattan this fall. Here is what Bucket Listers has confirmed, what is still unknown, and how to join the waitlist.
Forty-Eight Days to Pie: A Diner Countdown to Thanksgiving
A dated countdown from October 9 to Thanksgiving: the diner pie case, a viral Deer Park turkey pizza, and what the sources say Long Island eats this fall.
Sixteen Streetlights and 362 Years: The Road Through Mount Sinai
Sixteen new streetlights on Route 25A prompted a look back at Mount Sinai: a dry-stream name, a 1664 deed, Tallmadge’s 1780 landing, a farmland wedge saved from a big-box plan, and a harbor shaped by civic fights.
Phil’s Pizzeria & Restaurant — 265 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset, NY 11791
A nearly four-decade-old, family-owned Syosset pizzeria, a four-million-view TikTok catchphrase, and a Barstool Fund comeback: the story behind Phil’s Pizzeria.
